Real Estate Investing

How I Choose A Rental Property

How I Choose A Rental Property

How I Choose A Rental Property

Since I’ve acquired a few rental properties and have enjoyed some level of success I thought I’d share some things I’ve learned and my thoughts on how to best position yourself for success. I may have a slightly different perspective than most, but it’s based on real world experience, being open minded and flexible and constantly analyzing what is working and why. Most people look only at the numbers to determine if a rental property is a good investment or not. I, on the other hand, blend analytics with subjective factors that impact success.

Your Property Is A Product - Treat It Like One

In order to be successful in the Rental Property business you need to think of your rental property as a product that you’re selling. Whether you’re renting out a house long-term or plan to sell it, you have a product that you want people to pay for. Like any product there is always competition, so you’ll need a quality product that stands out among the rest. Emotion plays a large role when many people decide on a place to live. Ultimately this will be the home they will be living in for at least a year. Their decision taps into their emotional side and will be greatly impacted by things like; beautiful spa-like bathroom with soaking tub, upgraded kitchen with custom design elements, clean, nice paint, custom backsplash, porch swing/bench, large deck to entertain.

My First Rental Property - 3 Years Later

My First Rental Property - 3 Years Later

Looking Back At My First Rental Property

It’s been a little over 3 years since I purchased my first rental property so I thought it would be interesting to look back and see how I did. I learned a ton from the process of purchasing this property. Although this was the third property added to my real estate portfolio, I credit this little gem with being the catalyst for catapulting my real estate career. Check out my blog post, My First Rental Property, to read the full story of how I purchased this property.

3 Years Later

Estimated Value: $375,000

Price Appreciation: $219,500 (141%)

Loan Balance: $117,500

Estimated Net Rental Income (3yr):$15,600

Principle Pay Down: 7,000

Total Return (3yr): $242,100

ROI: 778% (259%/year)

My First Rental Property

My First Rental Property

Time To Reflect

It’s been a little over 3 years since I purchased my first rental property so I thought it would interesting to take a walk down memory lane. Although this was not the first piece of real estate I’ve ever purchased, this was the first house I purchase for the sole purpose of renting it out and holding it as an investment. Prior to the purchase of my first rental property in 2017 I purchased a Condo in 2009, which I turned into a rental in 2015. I also purchased a Townhouse as my primary residence in 2015. So although I had some experience purchasing real estate I had never purchased a piece of real estate as a pure investment.

The Backstory

To help paint the full picture of how I knew this particular house was the one for me and therefore was able to make a quick decision, I think it’s important to provide a little backstory. Towards the middle of 2016 I decided it was time to purchase my first single family house for the sole purpose of renting it. I had been observing areas in Southwest Atlanta that seemed full of potential with construction of the Beltline. I already noticed a lot of momentum and new development which was resulting in price appreciation. My main objective at the time was price appreciation, with cash flow being secondary. I wanted to keep the price of the house relatively low, to limit my risk, since this was going to be my first investment in a transitioning area. My main focus was on Adair Park and Capitol View since I had become familiar with those areas when I first starting looking at properties in 2015. Unfortunately by the time I was ready to jump in and pull the trigger, Adair Park and Capitol View had become extremely hot. The prices were rising to levels that I wasn’t comfortable with and the houses that were in my price range were in multiple offer situations. Long story short, I either couldn’t move fast enough or I repeatedly was outbid.

Don't Wait to Purchase Real Estate.

Don't Wait to Purchase Real Estate.

Should I wait for prices to decrease?

Disclaimer

Before I begin and before people misinterpret my statements I would just like to clarify that I am not saying everyone should rush out and buy a piece of real estate tomorrow. Investing in real estate is a major decision and should be made carefully and based on your individual situation. My overall stance is that if you are ready and have the desire to buy a house, don’t wait.

Some Background

Back in 2015 many people were telling me that they were going to hold off buying a house until prices came down. In their opinion prices had appreciated too much, so similar to how people try to time the stock market (buy low and sell high) they thought they could do the same with the real estate market. Many of these people felt very strongly, even though they were not in the real estate industry so did not understand the health and dynamics of the market. I attribute this to fear. Fear of either getting caught in another 2008 housing bubble/crash and being hurt financially or fear of looking stupid because they bought at the top. Fast forward 4 years and many properties in established or upcoming Atlanta neighborhoods have appreciated over 50%. If you factor in the use of leverage (small down payment with a mortgage for the balance) a 5x return on investments is not uncommon. So although we have experienced above normal price appreciation over the past few years and you might argue that hindsight is 20/20, I will explain why these results shouldn’t be a surprise. Even if a housing correction did take place, it was still a good time to buy if you had a long-term view.

Why it was wrong to wait in 2015

By 2015 houses in high-demand areas appreciated significantly from their lows in 2008, however in my opinion those were artificial lows. The economy was terrible and the housing collapse prevented banks from lending. That caused high-quality properties to drop well below what they were worth. As the economy started to improve many of those properties returned back to where they should have been priced in the first place. This appeared to some, who weren’t following the real estate market closely, as extraordinary price increases however, it was just things returning back to normal. It was clear that the most desirable areas in Atlanta were going to continue to appreciate at a solid rate. In 2015 the market became extremely hot because of a number of factors.